Christian 03
Official Obituary of

Thomas L. Scheuerman

September 22, 1949 ~ October 23, 2026 (age 77) 77 Years Old

Thomas Scheuerman Obituary

Thomas Lance Scheuerman was born on September 22, 1949, and on a warm and beautiful fall day, on October 23, 2026, while he was blowing leaves and tending to his yard like he loved to do, with the sun upon his face, his heart got tired and he left this world. It’s ironic that a “bad heart” might be the reason we didn’t get more time with Tom, because in all of his living Tom had the very best heart.

Tom was born in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, to Casper (“Bud”) and Karla Scheuerman (nee Westphal), joining big brother, Jim, and later taking that title for himself when they welcomed their sister, Sue. Tom grew up attending Pentecost Lutheran Church on Burleigh, and while his youthful years may have been marred by several incidents involving tomatoes and baseballs and broken windows, Tom was kind, and gentle, profoundly patient, steadfastly faithful, and generous through and through. He graduated from Washington High School in 1967 and ultimately made his way to the University of Wisconsin-Madison where two of his great loves would begin: a lifelong passion for the Wisconsin Badgers, and an accidental meet cute at the Brat and Brau on campus with Nancy Ann Johnson, who would become his wife on August 19, 1972.   

Tom began his work in public accounting as a CPA with Grant Thornton in Madison. In 1983, Tom took an opportunity with Valley Bank in Appleton, and like so many things in life, he had no idea at the time just what a profound effect that move would have on him and his family. Tom held many core values in terms of his professional pursuits, but near the top of that list was the importance of surrounding yourself with people of the utmost character, humility, and integrity. When the small-town bank merged in the early 90s, in quintessential Tom fashion, he refused to compromise what was most important to him for paycheck and security. So, he took a leap of faith and changed careers. Tom approached so many things in life with the “there but for the grace of God go I” mentality, and God certainly did him a solid when he introduced Tom to John Pfefferle. John Pfefferle would become Tom’s mentor in a field that became Tom’s true passion; commercial real estate and development. Throughout Tom’s career at NAI Pfefferle, John was so much more than just a professional mentor to Tom; John was a valued business partner, a confidant, Tom’s North Star, and a trusted and cherished friend.

Tom loved Appleton and believed that it was important to serve his community. He was on the Board of Directors at LEAVEN and The Housing Partnership of the Fox Cities. Before his passing, he was passionately serving on the Crossways Camping Ministries Board, as he watched both his daughters and granddaughter, Quinn, grow in their own faith as campers at Pine Lake Lutheran Camp. As the devoted husband of a public-school teacher, Tom also valued the importance of education and alongside Nancy, he generously supported the Friends of the Appleton Public Library. To ensure education was accessible to everyone, Tom and Nancy created the Scheuerman Family Fund within the Appleton Education Foundation. Among so many other wonderful opportunities, the Scheuerman Family Fund helped bring a guest composer to Appleton East High School and one of the final things Tom got to enjoy in this life was the pleasure of watching the concert he helped make possible. 

Tom was a man of deep and profound faith. He was an active member at Prince of Peace Lutheran Church in Appleton and cherished his time with the members of the Men’s Wednesday Morning Group and sharing his gifts with their congregation as a member of the Canticle Choir.

Although Tom succeeded professionally, his greatest success story and source of greatest pride was his family. Nancy was the love of his life and with his signature twinkling eye and curled lip smirk, he would always joke about how lucky he was that Nancy tolerated him for her entire life. But loving Tom was the easiest thing in the world, and the greatest privilege. Tom didn’t spend a day doubting how much their life and love meant to her. Tom and Nancy had two daughters, Kristen and Erica. But if you knew Tom, he would have told you that his favorite role was his promotion to Pop when his granddaughter and sweetie, Quinn Virginia, joined the family. There was never going to be enough time because Tom was the brightest light, the kindest soul, and the most genuinely good man there ever was, but Tom spent the last 14 years making the most cherished memories with Quinn. He had the incredible fortune to be one of the FC Elite 14 Navy “Grands” and was on the sidelines this June in Indianapolis, where he got to watch every moment of Quinn and her teammates doing the unthinkable and making their dreams come true by winning a USAV National Championship. And just a few weeks ago, he got to attend one of Quinn’s Kimberly Papermakers Varsity volleyball games, where she was one of the featured players; when asked who she most looked up to, Quinn of course said her Pop.

Quinn wasn’t alone in her admiration for Pop; if you crossed paths with Tom, there is no doubt you understood the depth of Tom’s genuine care, compassion, and generous spirit. Tom will be profoundly missed by people who are too bountiful to count or name, from his cherished colleagues, his treasured friends, his extended family of cousins and nieces and nephews, Quinn’s Dad, Carl Knutson, and Tom’s church family to name a few.

Tom lived his life in a way that the Jewish faith recognizes as tikkun olam; to use your time and gifts to repair and improve the world. His legacy of stewardship, love, and gentle kindness will be fiercely carried on by his beloved wife of 54 years, Nancy; his two daughters, Kristen and Erica; his son-in-law, Monte Weiss and his children, Brynn, Brett, and Brody; his best friend and brother Jim (Su) Scheuerman and his sister, Sue (Jon) Zetlau; his in-laws, Gary (Judith) Johnson, Dave (Marcia) Johnson, and Eileen Johnson; and his sweetie, Quinn Knutson. Tom arrived in Heaven to reunite with his parents, Bud and Karla, his adored in-laws, Oscar and Lavina Johnson, his brother-in-law, Duane Johnson.

Micah 6:8 – "He has shown you, O mortal, what is good. And what does the Lord require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God."  Oh, how Tom will be  missed by those of us left here on Earth; it hurts too much to touch with words. Until we are all reunited with you again, go in peace you and good and faithful servant, Tom, to your eternal life, and carry all of the love you gave and received with you.

Funeral Services will be held at 5:00 p.m. on Friday, October 30, 2026, at Prince of Peace Lutheran Church, 2330 E. Calumet St., Appleton. Visitation will be at the church from 2:00 p.m. until the time of the service.  For online condolences, please visit www.valleyfh.com.

In lieu of flowers, please consider honoring Tom’s memory by helping to support the organizations he would have been giving generously to if he was still here: Prince of Peace Lutheran Church; Crossways Camping Ministries; and the Scheuerman Family Fund within the Appleton Education Foundation.

Tom was such a bright light; his eyes sparkled, he laughed at his own jokes before delivering the punchline, and he went through life exuding joy. Tom was looking forward to attending a Badgers’ volleyball game with Quinn and he would have been cheering on the Brew Crew. If you’re so inclined, we would encourage you to come and celebrate Tom’s life dressed in your very best Wisconsin Badgers, red & white, or Milwaukee Brewers, yellow & blue, apparel. 

To send flowers to the family, please visit our floral store.


Services

Visitation
Friday
October 30, 2026

2:00 PM to 5:00 PM
Prince of Peace Lutheran Church
2330 E. Calumet St.
Appleton, WI 54915

Funeral Service
Friday
October 30, 2026

5:00 PM
Prince of Peace Lutheran Church
2330 E. Calumet St.
Appleton, WI 54915

SHARE OBITUARY

© 2026 Valley Funeral Home. All Rights Reserved. Funeral Home website by CFS & TA | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Accessibility